| <<<
Chronological Index
>>>       
Thread Index
>>>
 
 Basically OK but a few comments
To: comments-root-ksk-06aug15@xxxxxxxxxSubject: Basically OK but a few commentsFrom: Stephane Bortzmeyer <bortzmeyer@xxxxxx>Date: Wed, 26 Aug 2015 11:49:14 +0200 
 > https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/root-zone-ksk-rollover-plan-draft-04aug15-en.pdf
>  
I find the ICANN document basically OK but:
* The "communication plan" seems a bit light. This will be _the_ big
problem since the document clearly says that RFC 5011 and software
updates won't be sufficient.
* Among the testbeds, Yeti <https://yeti-dns.org/> is not mentioned.
* About RFC 5011, the ICANN document mentions the risk of
non-implementation and the risk of bad implementation but not the risk
of bad configuration (for instance, the key in a directory where the
daemon cannot write, something current Unbound and BIND packages do
not handle automatically).
* On the governance side, the document only comes from US
organizations (ICANN, Verisign, NTIA)
 
 <<<
Chronological Index
>>>       
Thread Index
>>>
 
 |