ICANN ICANN Email List Archives

[crai-report]


<<< Chronological Index >>>    <<< Thread Index >>>

This vertical separation is unavoidable and is a must to achieve trans parency

  • To: crai-report@xxxxxxxxx
  • Subject: This vertical separation is unavoidable and is a must to achieve trans parency
  • From: "liana.ydisg@xxxxxxxx" <liana.ydisg@xxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Tue, 28 Oct 2008 07:23:28 GMT

This vertical separation is unavoidable and is a must to achieve transparency 
thus stability for long term

1.      The legal structure difference in the two will support separate 
accounting and statistics to be collected for different operation and access 
standard. 
Different legal structure does not bar the same persons operate in the two 
types of entities, but there should be, say, at least 50% of directors cannot 
be the same, to ensure enough separation on the data collected and thus form 
independent data set for the separation to be meaningful. 

2.      Allow registrar to operate both as registry and registrar to a certain 
point before they have to separate into two entities to encourage start-up 
operation without price cap.  This separation point should consider user vs. 
potential user ratio, not a simple registered or paying /non-paying user model. 
 Thus it should be a little more complex model with room for modification.  

       3.  Define registries as the primary network operators covering the 
global time zones and geographic area with registrars as backup operators in 
case a primary registry is failing to provide such a defined coverage in case 
of emergency, political upset, or natural disaster.    In such  case, the 
registrar is prepared to take over a missing registry as its own separation 
time comes.  Limit coverage for a time zone and an geographic area between 1-3 
primary registries.  This limitation will give enough competition among the 
registries and encouragement for being a first start-up registry and registrar 
of an open area or for an underserved community. 

Liana Ye
Y&D Information Systems Group, Inc. 
Belmont, California, USA

_____________________________________________________________
Free comparison of top car rental companies. Click Here!
http://thirdpartyoffers.juno.com/TGL2111/fc/Ioyw6iifl2jtzwRszNy25huKk2zStcByAmrcZI6N5BgLdTZkqkW6tW/?count=1234567890





<<< Chronological Index >>>    <<< Thread Index >>>

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Cookies Policy