Re: [gnso-acc-sgb] Additional Proposal

[Ross Rader <ross@xxxxxxxxxx>]

Margie Milam wrote:
> All:
>
>  
>
> Attached is an additional proposal which provides access for service 
> providers that use WHOIS for legitimate purposes.  There may be some 
> cross-over with respect to other proposals, but I added specifics to 
> address the unique aspects related to service providers. 

This is just broad enough to include most everyone. I didn't read it any 
further than "self certify that they offer anti-fraud services".

Tucows.com, our shareware download service, provides anti-fraud software 
for download - would this allow us to legitimately self-certify?

We could just make this easier on everyone and instead give everyone 
unfettered access to all of our sensitive customer data as long as they 
self-certify that they won't do bad things with the data.

I think this proposal needs some further refinement before it merits 
serious consideration.

-ross