Re: [gnso-dow123] Email from the Registry Constituency

[Thomas Keller <tom@xxxxxxxxxx>]

I support Miltons view. Including the changes would not reflect the
disucssions and positions we had over the last years.

Best,

tom

Am 06.03.2007 schrieb Milton Mueller:
> Maria:
> 
> >>> "Maria Farrell" <maria.farrell@xxxxxxxxx> 03/05/07 12:30 PM >>>
> >My understanding of our process is that task force members can 
> >request changes until the report is finalised. 
> 
> The problem is that the registry constituency is not
> requesting"finalizing" changes in the report, they are attempting to
> disavow their own position, while at the same time leaving in place an
> official constituency statement that completely contradicts what they
> are saying now.
> 
> This introduces a disequlibrium in the whole game that could opens us up
> to hours of more negotiations and renegotiations. I don't think it is
> fair or productive for ICANN to attempt to accommodate these kinds of
> maneuvers. As Tim said, if the RyC wants to change, they can change
> their vote on the Council, they can announce the reasons for it then,
> and they can issue a report explaining it if they want to. What they
> should not be allowed to do is renegotiate the entire report based on a
> disruptive change in their position when none of us has a proper change
> to respond to their proposed changes.  
> 
> At the very least, Maria, I would allow you to add a sentence such as
> this:
> 
> "After the final TF meeting, the Registry constituency announced that
> while prefers the Opoc solution to the Special Circumstances proposal it
> belives that the OPoC solution does not adequately address the question
> of access to unpublished data."
> 
> That is a factual statement -- it eliminates all the propaganda that
> Simon sought to insert into the executive summary and accurately
> summarizes the new RyC position.
> 
> I will completely and uncompromisingly oppose ANY other change to the
> report, I hope Tim and others will back me on that. 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 

Gruss,

tom

(__)        
(OO)_____  
(oo)    /|\     A cow is not entirely full of
  | |--/ | *    milk some of it is hamburger!
  w w w  w