[gnso-igo-ingo-qc] Qualification Spreadsheet Integrated
Good Evening Qualification Criteria Group Members: Here is an integrated version of our spreadsheet. We have reviewed the transcripts and email communication and have attempted to integrate all comments that we feel are appropriately included and representative of the Working Group and various organization's views. After reviewing both Evan's and Claudia's suggested inclusions, we have made the following decisions: * Some suggested criteria are more appropriately discussed in other small groups. These are: o What is the current incidence of fraudulent or misleading domains related the organization? (from Evan) - Best discussed under "Nature of the Problem." o Does the organization, or its subsidiaries, engage in ad-hoc domain creation to deal with unforeseen needs (ie: disaster relief)? (from Evan) - Best discussed under "Nature of the Problem" as it relates to increased likelihood of phishing and other fraudulent activities. o Does the organization currently use a domain name under .int? (from Evan) - Currently being discussed under "Eligibility Criteria" o Harm - with specified subgroups (from Claudia's email dated December 19, 2012) - Best discussed under "Nature of the Problem." * For those additional criteria that we added in the spreadsheet - we invite the individuals that suggested the additional criteria to fill out the corresponding fields of the spreadsheet as they are most likely to appropriately tailor the answers to the concerns that gave rise to the suggestion. In addition, we integrated the two spreadsheets by including Claudia's comments, either in the body of the spreadsheet if those comments represented a widely accepted viewpoint to the members of the WG and organizations or in "notes" if they did not. Thank you for your continued work on this issue. Best regards, Jim Bikoff, David Heasley and Kiran Malancharuvil Kiran J. Malancharuvil Silverberg, Goldman & Bikoff, L.L.P. Georgetown Place 1101 30th Street NW, Suite 120 Washington, DC 20007 (202) 944-3307 - office (619) 972-7810 - mobile kmalancharuvil@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:kmalancharuvil@xxxxxxxxx> This message from the law firm of Silverberg, Goldman & Bikoff LLP may contain confidential or privileged information. If you received this transmission in error, please call us immediately at (202) 944-3307 or contact us by e-mail at kmalancharuvil@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:kmalancharuvil@xxxxxxxxx>. Disclosure or use of any part of this message by persons other than the intended recipient is prohibited. Attachment:
IGO-INGO-Working-Tool - QC Changes - 1_7_13.xlsx
|