[gnso-ppsc-pdp] Recommended edits on Impact Analysis

[Avri Doria <avri@xxxxxxx>]

Hi,

Here is my proposal.

On 12 May 2011, at 11:05, Marika Konings wrote:

> 
> Recommendation 31.
> 
> The PDP-WT recommends that PDP WGs provide input on issues related to 
> implementation, impact (economic, business, social, operational, etc.) and 
> feasibility including, when considered appropriate:


The PDP-WT recommends that PDP WGs be required to provide input on issues 
related the implementation on all policy recommendations.  This input should 
include an analysis of the impacts of the policy, both positive and  negative, 
including but not limited to: economic, competition, operations, privacy and 
other human rights, scalability and feasibility.  When appropriate the 
following should be considered:

o Creation of detailed impact analysis reports on all relevant aspects of the 
policy recommendations;

> O Recommend the inclusion of implementation guidelines as part of the Final 
> Report;
> O Consultation with the WG / Council on the draft implementation plan;
> O The creation of an implementation team that consists of representatives of 
> the WG, amongst others, which would be tasked to review / provide input 
> during the implementation phase
> Further guidance on this issue is to be included in the PDP Manual.
> 


> In addition, the following language is included in the PDP Manual:
> 
> Once formed, the PDP Team is responsible for engaging in the collection of 
> information. If deemed appropriate or helpful by the PDP Team, the PDP Team 
> may solicit the opinions of outside advisors, experts, or other members of 
> the public. The PDP Team should carefully consider the budgetary impacts, 
> implementability, and/or feasibility of its proposed information requests 
> and/or subsequent recommendations.
> 
> And
> 
> After collection and review of information, the PDP Team and Staff are 
> responsible for producing an Initial Report. The Initial Report should 
> include the following elements:
> · Compilation of Stakeholder Group and Constituency Statements
> · Compilation of any statements received from any ICANN Supporting 
> Organization or Advisory Committee
> · Recommendations for policies, guidelines, best practices or other proposals 
> to address the issue
> · Statement of level of consensus for the recommendations presented in the 
> Initial Report
> · Information regarding the members of the PDP Team, such as the attendance 
> records, Statements of Interest, etc.
> · If applicable, input on issues related to implementation, impact (economic, 
> business, social, operational, etc) and feasibility including the inclusion 
> of implementation guidelines

recommend replacing this last one with:

- impact analysis, both positive and negative, on all issues related to 
implementation including but not limited to economic, competition, operations, 
privacy and other human rights, scalability and feasibility.

> 
> These elements may be included as content within the Initial Report or by 
> reference to information posted on an ICANN website (such as through a 
> hyperlink).
>