Re: [gnso-rap-dt] RAPWG agenda for April 13

["李光皓" <Liguanghao@xxxxxxxx>]

Dear Greg: 

I am out in traveling, so I won't be able to attend tonight's meeting.　　
　　　　　

Best Regards,


Guanghao Li
China Internet Network Information Center (CNNIC)
Phone：86-10-58813176
Fax：86-10-58812666
Liguanghao@xxxxxxxx
2009-04-13

======== 2009-04-13 05:09:58 您在来信中写道： ========

Dear group:
 
Agenda for the meeting on Monday 13 April at 14:30 UTC (07:30 PDT, 10:30 EDT, 
15:30 London, 16:30 CEST) is:
 
Roll-call 
Walk-through of the attached document. 
Discussion of the term “registration”.  Does it mean creation of a domain name, 
and/or domain life-cycle operations, or something else?  (cf. Issues Report) 
Action items for April 27th meeting. 
 
With best wishes,
--Greg
 



From: Marika Konings [mailto:marika.konings@xxxxxxxxx] 
Sent: Wednesday, April 01, 2009 5:28 AM
To: gnso-rap-dt@xxxxxxxxx
Subject: [gnso-rap-dt] Updated RAPWG Definitions document
 
Dear All,

Please find attached and posted on the Wiki 
(https://st.icann.org/reg-abuse-wg/index.cgi?registration_abuse_policies_working_group)
 the updated RAPWG definitions document which includes additional columns for 
the different abuse categories as well as a number of variations of the 
definition of abuse for consideration. Please note that I have taken the 
liberty to add to the list a definition of misuse that was developed in the 
context of another GNSO Working Grouping (the Whois Study Group) which might 
provide some additional ideas for consideration. 

To facilitate the discussion on the definition of abuse on the mailing list, 
you will find the relevant section pasted below. Please feel free to share your 
comments and suggestions on the mailing list.

With best regards,

Marika 

==================

From the RAPWG Definitions (31 March 2009)

Abuse

Original proposal: 
Malicious or wrongful use causing harm or potential harm to registrants and 
Internet users.

Variations suggested on the RAP WG Conference Call (30 March) and Adobe Connect:

a) Malicious or illegal use causing harm to registrants and Internet users
b) Malicious or fraudulent use causing harm or potential harm to registrants 
and Internet users
c) Malicious or fraudulent use causing harm or intended harm to registrants and 
Internet users
d) Conduct which uses a domain name or IP address to cause harm or potential 
harm to any third party
e) Malicious or fraudulent use causing harm or undue harm to registrants and 
Internet users
f) To treat in a harmful, injurious or offensive way
g) Conduct with no legitimate use or purpose which uses a domain name or IP 
address to cause harm or potential harm         to any third party
h) Malicious or wrongful use causing harm or potential harm to third parties
i)  Malicious or wrongful use causing harm or potential harm to the Internet 
Community
j)  An activity that imposes negative (economic or other) effects upon another 
party

k) Misuse is an action that causes actual harm, is the predicate to such harm, 
is illegal or illegitimate, or is otherwise considered contrary to intention 
and design of a stated legitimate purpose, if such purpose is disclosed. (from 
the Whois Draft Working Definitions prepared by the GNSO drafting team)

Questions raised: How to judge intent? Should intent be part of the definition 
of abuse? How do you deal with conduct / technologies that are not malicious by 
nature, but become abusive in the way they are being used (intent) e.g. fast 
flux? Should a definition include who is targeted by the abuse? How do you 
qualify harm or potential harm? How can harm be further defined?

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =