Re: [gnso-synchronization-thickwhois] FW: Synchronization Subgroup work

[Susan Kawaguchi <susank@xxxxxx>]

Hello All, 

Since we have not had much email discussion on synchronization should we
assume there are no currently identified issues with synchronization of
the whois record between the registry and registrar?

In my mind the issue of authoritativeness is more crucial.  If the
registry or registrar is deemed authoritative then one would always know
to go to that source for the record.


Susan Kawaguchi
Domain Name Manager
Facebook Legal Dept.

Phone - 650 485-6064





On 2/4/13 6:57 PM, "Don Blumenthal" <dblumenthal@xxxxxxx> wrote:

>These questions primarily are within registrars' bailiwick, at least to
>start the process. How many Rr folks do we have in our subgroup? Beside
>the one that's obvious in Jill's sig, of course. :)
>
>Don
>
>From: Jill Titzer <jtitzer@xxxxxxxxxxx<mailto:jtitzer@xxxxxxxxxxx>>
>Date: Monday, February 4, 2013 7:53 PM
>To: Susan Kawaguchi <susank@xxxxxx<mailto:susank@xxxxxx>>,
>"gnso-synchronization-thickwhois@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:gnso-synchronization-thi
>ckwhois@xxxxxxxxx>"
><gnso-synchronization-thickwhois@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:gnso-synchronization-thi
>ckwhois@xxxxxxxxx>>
>Subject: RE: [gnso-synchronization-thickwhois] FW: Synchronization
>Subgroup work
>
>When is our next call?  Could everyone have information ready by then?
>
>
>_______________________
>Jill Titzer
>GoDaddy.com<http://GoDaddy.com>
>jtitzer@xxxxxxxxxxx<mailto:jtitzer@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>
>Work+1 480 505 8800 extension 4464
>Mobile +1 602 561 9707
>Fax +1 480 247 4084
>[cid:icon_sm_twitter.gif@3fe23e56ce4a6a1924df931ebe01b4b2]Jill_Tz<http://t
>witter.com/Jill_Tz>
>Skype: JATitzer1
>
>Typical Time Zone = UTC -7 (US Mountain)
>
>
>
>
>
>-------- Original Message --------
>Subject: [gnso-synchronization-thickwhois] FW: Synchronization Subgroup
>work
>From: Susan Kawaguchi <susank@xxxxxx<mailto:susank@xxxxxx>>
>Date: Mon, February 04, 2013 2:37 pm
>To: 
>"gnso-synchronization-thickwhois@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:gnso-synchronization-thi
>ckwhois@xxxxxxxxx>"
><gnso-synchronization-thickwhois@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:gnso-synchronization-thi
>ckwhois@xxxxxxxxx>>
>
>Hello All,
>
>Thought I would resend this email from December.  We discussed some of
>these questions on the group call in December but as a sub team we need
>to provide input on synchronization.
>
>Any thoughts?
>Susan Kawaguchi
>Domain Name Manager
>Facebook Legal Dept.
>
>Phone - 650 485-6064
>
>From: Susan kawaguchi <skawaguchi@xxxxxx<mailto:skawaguchi@xxxxxx>>
>Date: Mon, 17 Dec 2012 11:40:41 -0800
>To: 
><gnso-synchronization-thickwhois@xxxxxxxxx<mailto:gnso-synchronization-thi
>ckwhois@xxxxxxxxx>>
>Subject: Synchronization Subgroup work
>
>Hello All,
>
>With the holidays approaching fast I am not sure what we can get done on
>our sub team but I thought starting a discussion on email would be a good
>start.
>
>
>Synchronization/migration:  what wouldbe the impact on the registry and
>registrar WHOIS and EPP systems for thoseRegistries currently operating a
>thin registry, both in the migration phase to 'thick' WHOIS as well as
>ongoing operations?
>
>Since I am not involved in a registry or registrar I am sure you have
>many more thoughts on how this would work.
>
>A few questions:
>
>Does the registrar  retain the full WHOIS record for thick WHOIS
>registries currently or do they only retain the customer info which may
>include all the Thick WHOIS information?
>
>Since the registrars are already sending some WHOIS info to the registry
>for .com and .net how would this impact synchronization if we require
>they send the whole record.
>
>Other than the magnitude of the number of records that a registrar would
>have to submit to the .com registry how would requiring the whole record
>be any different than what they are already doing with the other gTld
>registries?
>
>Best regards,
>
>Susan Kawaguchi
>Domain Name Manager
>Facebook Legal Dept.
>
>Phone - 650 485-6064