Richard-you mention rules and contract. Where does it say that
registrars were not allowed to register sunrise names? A check of Google
reveals that Grabensee is a trademark lawyer. (http://www.grabensee.com)
Maybe he registered names for his clients, like other lawyers.
Afilias's
site says "Each registrar was allowed to reserve up to ten (10) names under the terms
spelled out in Exhibit E, Section V.5 of the Registry-Registrar Agreement that is
part of ICANN's agreement with Afilias." These names were reserved before Startup
started, so the registrars could register their site names in .info and no one could
squat on them. Logical, although it looks like some registrars used to opportunity
to register some names that have nothing to do with their registration buisinesses.
Can't find anything that prevented registrars from participating in Sunrise like
anyone else. Have you seen anything?