Return to newtlds Forum - Message Thread - FAQ

Username: see
Date/Time: Mon, June 19, 2000 at 5:25 AM GMT (Mon, June 19, 2000 at 1:25 AM EDT)
Browser: Microsoft Internet Explorer V5.01 using Windows 98
Score: 5
Subject: Wait until ISO 3166-1 includes it.

Message:
 

 
      The European Union, since it does not have an ISO 3166-1 Alpha-2 code element, has yet to qualify for a ccTLD under long-established ICANN/IANA policy (see RFC 1591).  (The ISO 3166 group has reserved the EU Alpha-2 code element for it, but it has not institutionalized and may never institutionalize the EU Alpha-2 code element as part of the ISO 3166-1 standard.)

      If ICANN grants the .eu domain, then it will have moved into the realm of deciding what is or is not a country for purposes of a ccTLD.  This will unecessarily politicize decsions, as revolutionary, extralegal, and other governments demand that they also be allowed as exceptions to the ISO 3166 standard.

      For example, should Lebanon still have one, despite the Syrian military presence?  If so, then why not the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, which is politically separated from the Republic of Cyprus by a Turkish military presence?  What about Kosovo?

      And why not other international orgaizations?  Should ICANN really be in the buisness of deciding if international organizations like NAFTA, OAS, OAU, ASEAN, the Arab Leauge, CARICOM, CIS, or any of dozens of others are "important" enough to qualify for their own domains?  CARICOM in particular has a number of parallels to the EU, including having many of its states having the same currency, high court, basic legal system, and common defense treaties.

      So let's wait until the EU has an ISO 3166-1 entry.
 


Message Thread:


Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Cookies Policy