Return to newtlds Forum - Message Thread - FAQ

Username: GALund
Date/Time: Fri, July 7, 2000 at 11:50 AM GMT
Browser: Microsoft Internet Explorer V5.0 using Windows NT
Score: 5
Subject: Abolish TLDs instead!

Message:
 

 
                I would argue that TLDs such as .com, etc be abolished rather than extended. The only top-level domains required should be geographical.

The domain hierachy exists to allow to identical names to coexist. But this is exactly what leads to trademark disputes and expense, slowing down the spread of the Internet into smaller companies.

Wherever two organisations have the same name, the chances are that their customer base / target audience are separated geographically anyway. If they are not separated, problems would exist already.

For example, why introduce a '.movie' hierachy? - movie names are hardly ever going to clash with the name of an existing organisation. Where in specific cases clashes happened, ICANN could implement a specific and consistent policy eg insist that '-movie' be appended to the name. No more typing involved but one less regulatory organisation to be created :-)

A multitude of TLDs will only serve to confuse Internet users, particularly people who are not regular users or who currently have little or no exposure to how the system is organised. In other words, the vast majority of people around the world who have not yet had the opportunity to use the Internet.

Names should be assigned on strict criteria as to whether the company / organisation is global or should be placed in a regional (eg .eu) or country-specific TLD. A transfer to a consistent scheme within countries should also be adopted along similar lines.

My two pence
     
     
     

 


Message Thread:


Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Cookies Policy