Re: [gnso-igo-ingo] MP3 IGO-INGO Protections Policy Development Process (PDP) Working Group - 14 November 2012

[Robin Gross <robin@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Please note that I participate as NCSG.  I am listed below as NCUC and that 
should be changed in the record for this call to NCSG and also please keep in 
mind for my future participation.

Thank you,
Robin Gross, NCSG Chair


On Nov 15, 2012, at 8:12 AM, Julia Charvolen <julia.charvolen@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Dear All,
>  
> The next call for the IGO-INGO Protections Policy Development Process (PDP) 
> Working Group is scheduled on Wednesday 28 November 2012 at 15:00 UTC
>  
> Please find the MP3 recording of the IGO-INGO Protections Policy Development 
> Process (PDP) Working Group  teleconference held on Wednesday 14 November 
> 2012  at 1900 UTC at:
>  
> http://audio.icann.org/gnso/gnso-igo-ingo-20121114-en.mp3
>  
> On page: http://gnso.icann.org/calendar/#nov
>  
> The recordings and transcriptions of the calls are posted on the GNSO Master 
> Calendar page:
> http://gnso.icann.org/calendar/
>  
>  
> Attendees:
> Alan Greenberg – ALAC
> Chuck Gomes - RySG
> Lanre Ajayi - Nominating Committee Appointee
> Osvaldo Novoa-ISPC
> Chuck Gomes - RySG
> Kiran Malancharuvil – IPC
> Jim Bikoff – IPC
> Brett Faussett – IPC
> David Maher – RySG
> Stephane Hankins - IPC
> Elizabeth Finberg – RySG
> Thomas Rickert – Nominating Committee Appointee
> Mary W.S Wong - NCSG
> David Heasley - IPC
> Avri Doria – NCSG
> David Opderbeck - NCSG
> Ricardo Guilherme - RySG
> Evan Lebovitch – ALAC
> Robin Gross - NCUC
> Heidi Vanderveen – At Large
>  
> Apology : 
> Gregory Shatan – IPC
> Iliya Bazlyankov – RrSG
> Paul Diaz – RySG
> Christopher Rassi – Red Cross
>  
>  
> ICANN Staff:
> Margie Milam
> Barbara Roseman
> Brian Peck
> Berry Cobb
> Glen De Saint Géry
> Julia Charvolen
> 
>  
> ** Please let me know if your name has been left off the list **
>   
> Thank you.
> Kind regards,
> Julia Charvolen
> For GNSO Secretariat
>  
> Adobe Chat Transcript:
>  Berry Cobb:Welcome to the 14 NOV IGO-INGO Conference Call.
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):hello all
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:Hello all.  I'm here with Jim Bikoff and David Heasley. 
>  
>   Bret Fausett, Uniregistry:I will have to leave the call after the first 
> hour, if it goes that loong, to attend the ICANN New gTLD     Webinar.
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:nice try Brian
>   Mary Wong:Hi everyone, sorry I'm late (had another mtg in a different bldg).
>   Berry Cobb:Thank you Kiran.  I had missed his changes within the email 
> chain.
>   Bret Fausett, Uniregistry:Not to mention olympic.com.
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:Thanks Berry. Sorry for being a pain, but can you add 
> the additional paragraph from the  IOC at the end of Greg's changes?
>   Berry Cobb:Kiran, I'm having difficulty finding it.  Can you cut & paste 
> the first 5 or so words so that I may search for it?
>   elizabeth.finberg:The GNSO Resolution establsihing this PDP specifically 
> asks us to address Red Cross/IOC
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:We were just disconnected, trying to reconnect
>   Berry Cobb:@ Kiran, got it now.
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:great...just found it myself
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:asking them not to duplicate efforts does not pre
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:*prejudice other organizations
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:it's directed to GC
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:that's fine with us
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:thank you Ricardo for suggesting an acceptable solution
>   Thomas Rickert:I am suffering from some technical issues. Just got a new 
> router installed in my hotel room so I can at least access adobe.
>   Thomas Rickert:Can I have a dial-out again, please!
>   Thomas Rickert:My line was disconnected, too :-(
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):"…taking into account the work 
> previously done as well as any relevant information shared on IGOs/IOC/Red 
> Cross Red Crescent…"and including IGOs below as well (.
>   Mary Wong:NCSG is fine with the language as is, though we take Ricardo's 
> point.
>   Berry Cobb:Ricard, can you please provide your revision here in the text 
> box please?
>   Berry Cobb:Ricardo.  sorry.
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:yes, please provide your revision in the chat so we can 
> see please.
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):here it is: "...and research on 
> the topic. be provided.."
>   David Maher:+1
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:that's fine with us
>   David Maher:+1
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):so the beginning could read as 
> follows as well: "....taking into account the work previously done (including 
> any previous correspondence, determination and research on the topic)..."
>   David Maher:+1
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):yes, it's better now
>   Mary Wong:Fine by us (NCSG).
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):+1
>   Berry Cobb:v4.1 Adopted by WG of GCO Request was just sent to the mail list.
>   Bret Fausett, Uniregistry:I need to drop from this call and hop onto 
> another ICANN conference. I will look forward to listening to the MP3 and 
> reading the minutes.
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):I second Alan's comment, which 
> mirror some of my concerns
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):I mean "mirrors"
>   Berry Cobb:Council Call is at 11:00 UTC
>   elizabeth.finberg:my call just dropped.  dialing back in
>   Alan Greenberg:GAC advice is not binding on the GNSO. In fact, it is not 
> binding on the Board, but if the Board chooses to not follow GAC advice, 
> there is a carefully laid out process to follow.
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):perhaps we can craft some 
> language around that
>   Evan Leibovitch:Why is that necessary?
>   Alan Greenberg:Good question Evan.We all know that we reject GAC adviec at 
> our peril. ANd we wouldbe foolish to do that without conscious action.
>   David Maher:I'm available on the 21st
>   Berry Cobb:Retreat does not equal a ski trip to the Alps.  We're working!  
> :-(
>   Thomas Rickert:sorry my line was cut
>   Thomas Rickert:since I cannot discuss with you now, I would like to NOT 
> skip two subsequent weeks
>   Kiran Malancharuvil:that's fine with us
>   David Maher:I have to drop off. Sorry
>   Ricardo GUILHERME (Universal Postal Union):I must leave the call as well; 
> thank you to all and have a good night (I am sending, to the ICANN staff, the 
> proposed language relating to my first remark within the next minutes). Thanks
>   Mary Wong:Thanks, Thomas, Berry, Brian and everyone - talk to you soon!