RE: [gnso-igo-ingo] SG/C Request for Input v0.4
I have attached revisions and comments to the SG/C Request for Input. My two comments are as follows: 1. I think it needs to be within the remit of this WG to determine whether the limitation to organizations "receiving protections under treaties and statutes under multiple jurisdictions" is appropriate, or whether it is a distinction without a difference, or whether some other limitation is necessary and appropriate (and if so, what it is). International and treaty law is fairly complex, and there may be instances where a treaty was written so it doesn't require enabling legislation in member states, or instances where there is a web of multi-national statutory regulation but no treaty (e.g., I believe Big Brother Big Sister organizations are protected in multiple jurisdictions, but not by treaty). I don't think names with multinational protections should be disqualified based on how those protections were arrived at - to do so would be arbitrary and unfair. I don't think we need a Charter amendment to have that discussion; however, if we do, I would propose that we start that process immediately. 2. Given Berry's comment regarding edits to the quoted language of the Charter, we need to either (a) revert to the language of the Charter, (b) change the lead-in, so these are not identified as statements from the Charter per se, (c) amend the Charter to reflect these points, or (d) put the non-Charter language in a sub-bullet that makes clear it is a comment to the Charter language and not part of the Charter language. Greg From: owner-gnso-igo-ingo@xxxxxxxxx [mailto:owner-gnso-igo-ingo@xxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Berry Cobb Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 6:14 PM To: gnso-igo-ingo@xxxxxxxxx Subject: [gnso-igo-ingo] SG/C Request for Input v0.4 Team, Attached is the latest version (redline & clean) of the SG & C input request template. Please send any other suggested changes to the list and I will incorporate into the master. We will review this at our next meeting on Wednesday 5 DEC @ 19:00 UTC. Thank you. B Berry Cobb Internet Corporation for Assigned Names & Numbers (ICANN) 720.839.5735 mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx<mailto:mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> @berrycobb Attachment:
IGO-INGO_Input_Request_SG-C_v0 4_redline.DOC
|