[gnso-igo-ingo] IGO Organization Survey / Domain Registration Analysis
Team, Attached is a spreadsheet evolved from the analysis started by Alan Greenberg and supported by other in the WG that should be performed to further define the nature of the problem. At this stage, we are looking for the WG to comment on this approach before we continue "filling in the blanks." If the WG agrees with this approach, we can then discuss a divide and conquer strategy to complete the analysis. A few notes about the SS: 1. The 1st tab, "data_gather_form" is a list of the items Alan suggested we request information from organizations seeking protection. Other WG members seemed to agree with this list of questions. I'd like to ask the WG to review and recommend additional types of information that we should possibly request. A possible tool to solicit this feedback from the organizations is to construct a survey and distribute to organizations identified for completion. ICANN has deployed a survey tool (LimeSurvey) that may benefit this exercise (https://limesurvey.icann.org/), and it may aid in generating useful statistics to aid in the analysis. 2. The 2nd tab, "registration_by_org_by_tld" is a matrix evolved from the analysis performed by Alan, and it also includes responses submitted by the IOC. Several notes about this framework: a. The organizations listed here are the organizations list in the 13DEC11 letter to ICANN signed by NGOs. It also includes UNICEF (from Alan's PDF analysis) that was not a signatory of the letter. b. Not all identifiers from the IOC and RCRC are included at this point. We can add them to this analysis after we agree to the approach. c. I only completed the IOC identifiers as a working example. As you will see we have much more to complete once finalized. d. Countrycodes listed next to the TLDs are not all inclusive, but I attempted to pick the larger ccTLDs. We can add others as necessary. e. The remainder of TLD types are divided by generic, generic-restricted, and sponsored as defined by IANA Root Zone dB f. Cells with Green Fill and White letters are an indication that the site may have legitimate use, as first identified by Alan g. We may want to further define meta-tags for domains that are registered, but not controlled by the respective organization (i.e. do we tag by malicious use, monetary gain, for sale, etc..) h. Stats at the bottom of the chart for each organization are meant to: . Determine total % of identifier domains as registered across the various TLDs . Then a % of domains registered as a breakout of TLD type . Each is compared alongside as to whether the respective org has control of the domain or not We welcome your input to this tool. Please provide feedback over the list, and we will discuss this approach at our meeting next week. Thank you. B Berry Cobb Internet Corporation for Assigned Names & Numbers (ICANN) 720.839.5735 <mailto:mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx @berrycobb Attachment:
IGO-INGO_Abuse_Evaluation_Workbook_v0.1.xlsx
|