[gnso-igo-ingo] Informal midway update on NCSG discussions on 'consensus' points.

[Avri Doria <avri@xxxxxxx>]

Hi,

An update on the positions inside the NCSG.  

Or at least my view of it - NCSG, like ALAC, lists are all open archive so 
anyone can make their own evaluation.

The NCSG is still deliberating.

On some topics, we have a range of views ranging from: 

a - No Specal Privileges  For anyone  to 
  Let a restricted set of IGO, International Organizations and INGOs use 
Objection procedures and RPMs

b - Let INGOs use trademarks like everyone else  to 
     Accreditation by ECOSOC is equivalent to the IGO treaty requirements and 
stands in fair stead to business oriented trademarks

c  - IGO/INGO pay like everyone else to use RPMs to
    Giving them a break given their not-for-profit status 

The things I think we are agreed on, though I am still checking - BCC'ing this 
message to our open discussion list. -

I - In all issues we tend toward a fair and equivalent standard of treatment.  
This is not just a throw away excuse as some may have characterized, but rather 
is an important driving principle in NCSG considerations.

II - We do not support blocking of names at either the first or second level.  
That is we do not support expanding the reserved name list in any way.

III - We do not support giving those on reserved name lists (if they are 
expanded) a special privilege of exception from the reserved name list.

IV - We should not decide any policy issue based on the degree to which someone 
has lobbied the GAC and gotten them to issue Advice.   We should consider the 
Advice as one among many issues but not be ruled by it. 

I have not yet broached the issue of:

- Do Incumbents have to obey the same rules as new gTLDs, and what implications 
does this have for the renewal and transfer of current registration of names 
that may be have been added to the reserved list.  Is there a 'grandmother' 
rule?


I hope to have completed NCSG consensus opinion by next week's meeting.

avri

Writing as Alternate Chair of the NCSG Policy Committee in the midst of trying 
to determine our position.