RE: [gnso-vi-feb10] SRSU

[Milton L Mueller <mueller@xxxxxxx>]

In my view, the justification for the exception is simply and flatly that it is 
a SRSU domain. It is the SR's own name space. One cannot require them to use 
registrars any more than one can require General Electric to outsource their 
private corporate network management. GE may indeed choose to outsource it, but 
it's their network and their choice. There should be no requirement to 
demonstrate a "valid, plausible need" to not use registrars. For SRSU, the 
opposite is the case: there must be a valid, plausible need for registrars to 
demonstrate to the SRSU delegee that they are needed.  

> -----Original Message-----
> I see this as the only possible exception to SRSU, but even then I would
> require the registry to demonstrate their need for the exception from
> granting equal access. There must be a valid, plausible need for such en
> exception, or equal access should apply.
> 
> Volker