[bc-gnso] RE: .CAT WHOIS Proposed Changes - call for public comments

[Elisa Cooper <Elisa.Cooper@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

To summarize the proposed change, the .Cat registry is requesting that 
provisions are made to WHOIS requirements in order to comply with EU privacy 
laws. If approved, WHOIS records for companies, businesses, partnerships, 
non-profit entities, associations, etc. would remain publicly available. 
However, domain name registrants that are individuals would be given the option 
to elect whether or not their WHOIS records would be made publicly available.

A similar request was submitted by the .Tel registry in 2007.

In response to the .Tel request, the BC recommended that 1) the request should 
not be handled as a "proposal for a new registry service" but instead should 
follow the "ICANN Procedure for Handling WHOIS Conflicts with Privacy Law", and 
2) should the proposal not be withdrawn and re-directed as above, ICANN must 
reject the proposal, as the proposal fails to adequately balance the needs of 
all stakeholders and affected parties who use the WHOIS.

Regardless of the BC's comments, the .Tel request was ultimately approved.

I assume that our position still stands, and that we believe that this .Cat 
request should not be handled as a "proposal for a new registry service", and 
that if it is not treated in that way, that we would ask ICANN to reject the 
proposal, as not every registrant (even though the majority likely are) is 
subject to EU law.

Best,
Elisa

Elisa Cooper
Director of Product Marketing
MarkMonitor

208 389-5779 PH
From: Marilyn Cade [mailto:marilynscade@xxxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Saturday, January 21, 2012 8:48 AM
To: Elisa Cooper; bc - GNSO list
Subject: .CAT WHOIS Proposed Changes - call for public comments

Elisa Cooper, the BC WHOIS Rapporteur, or Steve DelBianco, V.Chair, Policy 
Coordination, may offer additional comments.
The Chair's purpose is to forward to all BC members.

Like all members, I look to our Rapporteur for WHOIS, supported by our Vice 
Chair, Policy Coordination,  to advise.
However, for any new members, WHOIS is a key priority for BC.

Marilyn Cade, BC Chair



http://www.icann.org/en/announcements/announcement-20jan12-en.htm
.CAT WHOIS Proposed Changes

Forum Announcement: Comment Period Opens on Date: 20 January2012

Categories/Tags: Contracted Party Agreements

Purpose (Brief):
ICANN is opening today the public comment period for the Fundacio puntCAT's, 
request to change its Whois according to EU data protection legislation. The 
public comment period will be closed on 3 March 2012.
The .cat registry, submitted a Registry Service Evaluation Process (RSEP) on 
August 2011.
At this time, ICANN has conducted a preliminary review in accordance with the 
Registry Services Evaluation Policy and process set forth at 
http://www.icann.org/registries/rsep/rsep.html. ICANN's preliminary review 
(based on the information provided) did not identify any significant 
competition, security, or stability issues.
The implementation of the request requires an amendment to the .cat Registry 
Agreement signed 23 September 2005. This public forum requests comments 
regarding the proposed amendment.
Public Comment Box Link: 
http://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/cat-whois-changes-18jan12-en.htm