Re: [gnso-dow123] Final Task Force Report on Whois Services

["David W. Maher" <dmaher@xxxxxxx>]

Jordyn:
Your wording is correct for the Registry Constituency. Milton's 
wording is not correct.
David

At 04:23 PM 3/6/2007, Jordyn Buchanan wrote:
> I actually lifted that sentence almost directly from an e-mail from a
> registry constituency rep, but I'm glad to allow them to clarify this
> point.
>
> Jordyn
>
> On 3/6/07, Milton Mueller <Mueller@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> > I have reviewed only the executive summary. Not bad, overall. One
> > modification that needs to be made in this sentence:
> >
> > "The Registry Constituency, which voted in favor of the OPOC proposal,
> > believes that considerable work still needs to be done to address the
> > issue of access to non-public Whois information by law enforcement and
> > others with a legitimate need for access."
> >
> > My understanding is that the RyC's support access for law enforcement
> > but not necessarily "others." Therefore the last part of this sentence
> > must be stricken as it does not reflect their consensus views, and
> > should read as follows:
> >
> > ""The Registry Constituency, which voted in favor of the OPOC proposal,
> > believes that considerable work still needs to be done to address the
> > issue of access to non-public Whois information by law enforcement."