Re: [gnso-igo-ingo] Final Report v1.5.1

[Alan Greenberg <alan.greenberg@xxxxxxxxx>]

Regarding the transfer of protected names to a 
new registrant, the bullet within section 3.7 
current reads (after accepting current changes):
> If a second-level name that matches a protected 
> identifier, as identified via any consensus 
> policies defined here becomes eligible where the 
> last Registrant is not involved in any 
> subsequent ownership change, the name shall not 
> be eligible for registration or transfer and 
> become immediately reserved.  At the time the 
> name completes eligible grace periods and 
> becomes eligible for deletion, the name shall 
> not be reallocated by the Registry and shall be 
> deemed ineligible for registration per the defined policy.
I would suggest the following:

> The previous point notwithstanding, if a 
> second-level name that matches a protected 
> identifier, as identified via any consensus 
> policies defined here, may not be transferred to 
> a new registrant after expiration under 
> registration agreement terms which would 
> otherwise allow a registrar to, on its own 
> accord, auction, sell or otherwise effect a 
> change of registrant. Such registrations, if not 
> renewed by the Registrant at Expiration (as 
> defined in the Expired Registration Recovery 
> Policy) must be deleted by the registrar after 
> the termination of any renewal grace periods.
Alan


At 07/11/2013 12:32 AM, Berry Cobb wrote:
> WG Members,
>
> Please find attached the latest version of the 
> Final Report based on today’s WG 
> discussions.  We will review this version at 
> tomorrow’s WG meeting scheduled for 14 UTC.  We 
> also have a session scheduled for Friday at the 
> same time.  A few notes to consider about the Final Report:
> ·         All suggested changes to the Final 
> report shall be submitted to the list by 8 
> November 2013, 19:00 UTC.  We must meet the 10 
> Nov 2013, 23:59 UTC deadline to submit the 
> report and motion to the GNSO Council.
> ·         I only included the red-line Word 
> version of the report.  I also included a clean 
> PDF version for your reference.  If you have any 
> suggested changes or edits to the Final Report, 
> please make them in the Word document and submit 
> to the mailing list.  I will then import them into the master.
> ·         To meet the stated deadline above and 
> per our discussion in the WG meeting today, the 
> Minority Statements have been extracted from the 
> Final Report and they will be submitted as 
> supplement attachments to the Final Report.  I 
> included four attachments that represent the 
> minority positions that were included in the 
> draft version of the report.  WG members have 
> until 15 November 2013, 19:00 UTC to submit a 
> revision or new minority statement for your respective group.
> ·         As mentioned, the Public Comment 
> Review Tool and the Consensus Call documents 
> will also be included as supplements to the 
> Final Report so that readers of the report may 
> easily reference feedback from the community and stakeholders.
> ·         The draft resolution statements 
> document will be delivered to the mailing list via a separate email.
> Thank you for everyone’s participation today, and speak to you tomorrow.
>
> Thank you.  B
>
> Berry Cobb
> Internet Corporation for Assigned Names & Numbers (ICANN)
> 720.839.5735
> <mailto:mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>mail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
> @berrycobb