[gnso-policyimpl-wg] Notes and updated public comment review tool
Dear All, Please find below the notes from yesterday's meeting and attached the revised public comment review tool. With regard to comment 4.18, those on the call agreed to add the following to the principles section: The development and implementation of policy must have a basis in and adhere to standards of fairness, notice, transparency, integrity, objectivity, predictability and due process consistent with ICANN's core values and in particular its commitment to the global public interest as outlined in the ICANN Articles of Incorporation. Furthermore the WG agreed to add in the principles section on 'community': Whenever the Board determines that the recommendations of the GNSO do not, in its view, reflect a broader consensus including the advice of the Advisory Committees and public comments, it will use existing process mechanisms to either send the issue back to the GNSO for further consideration to initiate broader community discussion. All final recommendations would still be the responsibility of the GNSO. If you have any comments or concerns about this proposed language, please share those with the mailing list. The next meeting has been scheduled for Wednesday 15 April at 19.00 UTC for 90 minutes. Best regards, Marika Notes 8/4: Public comment 4.18: language proposed by Avri to address comment submitted. Update principle with 'in particular' (prior to the global public interest). All agreed to add principle to Final Report. Recommendation related to community - no objections to including it in the Final Report. Update Communities to Committees. Change 'based on' to 'including' and 'or' to 'and'. Change ''in their view' to 'its view'. Change 'or' to 'to' in second sentence. Change 'discover' to 'determines'. Where to include it in the report? Include in community section of report (section 4c(2). Action item: share updated language as agreed by those on the call with the list and encourage those not on the call to speak up if they disagree. 5.3 The GIP Team is encouraged...", etc. Add a sentence after that sentence (and in the same place in each of the three processes such as "In this regard, it is recommended that the GIP Team Leader or Chair consult with the GNSO Council GAC Liaison regarding the best way to achieve early GAC participation or consultation with respect to the issues under consideration." Attachment:
Public comment review tool - updated 8 April 2015.doc
|