Re: [gnso-raa-b] Revised draft of Section V

[Avri Doria <avri@xxxxxxx>]

Hi,

I know that I have not participated in this group, only monitored its mailing 
list.  And while there was nothing much controversial in parts 1-4, iI find 
that both options list in 5 are unsatisfactory.

We will be discussing this in the NCSG, but it will be my recommendation that 
neither of these options be supported in council but that the issue be 
discussed further to find a solution that includes greater inclusion in the 
discussion by the ICANN Stakeholders - especially the registrants but also both 
commercial and non commercial users.  The idea that even in the majority 
recommendation, the observers can be excluded is unacceptable.  While I was 
originally personally willing to  accept the status of Observer for non 
Registrar participants, by which I mean full transparency and full 
participation except for decision making,  after thinking further of the 
conditions being imposed and re-listening to some of the contribution made at 
yesterday's meeting, I have come to personally accept the position that full 
dialogue must be insisted upon.

a.



On 18 May 2010, at 11:39, Metalitz, Steven wrote:

> SubTeam B participants,
> Hi,
> Following up on yesterday's call, attached please find a proposed revision of 
> section V of the Initial Draft Report.  It lays out the two options for "next 
> steps," and includes a draft of a brief supporting statement for the option 
> that commands Strong Support within the SubTeam.  I understand that one of 
> the registrar representatives (perhaps Statton?) will draft a statement of 
> similar length for the alternative approach.  Of course, your comments and 
> edits on anything in this document are welcomed.  Please circulated these as 
> soon as possible, and in any case by Thursday of this week, so that we can 
> stay on track for circulation of a "final" draft by staff no later than next 
> Monday.  Thanks. 
> 
> Steve Metalitz
> 
> <<Section V draft (2697426).DOC>>
> 
>   
> <Section V draft (2697426).DOC>