RE: [gnso-raa-dt] Charter of rights - "wish list"

[Alan Greenberg <alan.greenberg@xxxxxxxxx>]

Tim, I understand what you are saying, but that does not seem to be a 
universal position, as discussed at the very end of the meeting 
today. There is a perception that the "Charter of Rights" activity 
(not the RAA process for which Steve is drafting a charter) should 
include two components, the existing rights (based on the work that 
Margie did) and a "What rights should be document" (in line with the 
more traditional definition of a Charter of Rights). It is that 
latter document that I was referring to.
Alan

At 03/08/2009 05:52 PM, Tim Ruiz wrote:
> Alan, that is why these efforts should be separate. Creating a postable
> charter based on existing rights/responsibilities could be a relatively
> quick endeavor. Discussions of *wish lists* is another matter entirely.
>
> The discussion on changes to the RAA that various parties would like to
> see should be an effort of its own. If there is a new registrant right
> or responsibility someone would like to see, or one that someone would
> like to change, it should be brought up in the RAA discussion group. But
> as I suggested, I think there should be a limited number of stakeholder
> *representatives* involved in this group who would bring such items to
> the table.
>
>
> Tim
>
> -------- Original Message --------
> Subject: [gnso-raa-dt] Charter of rights - "wish list"
> From: Alan Greenberg <alan.greenberg@xxxxxxxxx>
> Date: Mon, August 03, 2009 3:10 pm
> To: gnso-raa-dt@xxxxxxxxx
>
>
> I have some trouble understanding how we will arrive at the wish-list
> part of the charter development.
>
> Is this just going to be the registrant/users who develop it, or will
> this need to be done in conjunction with the registrars?
>
> If the latter, it sounds like it is replicating work that will need
> to be done by the future RAA working group (or whatever mechanism is
> used), and it also pre-supposes that the registrars are agreeing to
> such future rights in advance of the actual discussion/negotiation.
>
> Alan