FW: [jig] Friendly reminder: comments from WG members on Draft Summary and Analysis public comments Universal Acceptnace

["Edmon Chung" <edmon@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Thanks Bart again for putting this together.

Hi Everyone,

Thank you all those who provided their comments and feedback.

As discussed on our call earlier in the week, and seeing no further comments 
with the updated version from Bart, will consider the current draft finalized 
(attached again for your easy reference).

This will also serve as a last call, if we do not receive any objections within 
the next 24hrs, Bart will proceed to post the summary and complete the public 
comments process.

Edmon




-----Original Message-----
From: owner-jig@xxxxxxxxx [mailto:owner-jig@xxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Bart 
Boswinkel
Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2012 4:28 PM
To: jig
Subject: Re: [jig] Friendly reminder: comments from WG members on Draft Summary 
and Analysis public comments Universal Acceptnace

Dear all,
Included an updated version of the summary and analysis document (clean and 
redline).

With regard to the specific issue raised by Avri:
The topic has not been discussed by the JIG. In order to move forward I have 
included as suggested language that the JIG will provide clarification in its 
next report on IDN TLD's.

Please note also in this context that according to the FY2013 draft plan and 
budget one of the proposed projects relates to Universal Acceptance of TLD's ( 
see page 59, for a brief description), the leader of this ICANN project is 
already engaged with the JIG.

If the members of the JIG approve the final version, I will post it and the 
public forum can be formally closed.


Kind regards,
Bart
  
 


On 5/8/12 1:42 PM, "Avri Doria" <avri@xxxxxxx> wrote:

> 
> 
> On 1 May 2012, at 10:04, Bart Boswinkel wrote:
> 
>> Dear all,
>> Friendly reminder: To date I have received comments from Fahd. If you 
>> have any commen,t please sent them to the list over the next week. I 
>> will then consolidate them in the next version of the document which 
>> will be send to the group for discussion and adoption. The Summary 
>> and Analysis will have to be posted to close the public comment forum 
>> for the Initial Report on Universal Acceptance.
>> Thanks you and kind regards,
>> Bart
>> <Draft summary and analysis of comments JIG Interim Universal 
>> Acceptance.doc>
> 
> 
> Apologies for the late review.
> 
> In addition to some typo issues that I noted in a copy of the doc I am 
> sending to Bart, I do have one issue.
> 
> "
> At the same time, the RySG cautioned against the possible time it may 
> take to just answering all the questions raised ( and implicitly, the 
> resources needed to resolve the issues) to ensure universal acceptance 
> of IDN TLD¹s.[ "
> 
> This must have been discussed at a meeting I skipped. Apologies for that.
> 
> I understood the RySG comment to be asking for clarification on the 
> rseponse we really wanted from them.  And an inidication that it may 
> take a lot of time for them to provide the answers we might have been asking 
> for.
> 
> They ask for clarification.
> 
> "
> After reviewing the report, the RySG is not clear regarding the extent 
> of input being solicited.
> "
> 
> Did we do that?  Again, I have been distracted, missed a few meetings 
> (without catching up on the recordings - mea culpa ...) and don't recall.
> 
> thanks
> 
> avri
> 
> 
> 
>

Attachment: Draft summary and an#560468.doc
Description: MS-Word document

Attachment: Draft summary and analysis of comments JIG Interim Universal Acceptance v 2 clean.doc
Description: MS-Word document