Re: [soac-newgtldapsup-wg] Question 1: Size of applicant pool for support

[Avri Doria <avri@xxxxxxx>]

Dear Tijani,

On 31 Aug 2010, at 11:27, Tijani BEN JEMAA wrote:

> When you say that no consensus was reached on any of the part of the report, 
> I feel we wasted our time in discussing at length issues and put together 
> text for them, and Karla send the result on the list and ask to correct her 
> if she is wrong, and no objection raised, and yet, you say there is no 
> consensus?????


I say I am not ready to call consensus.  Calling consensus is one of the task 
of the co-chairs.  Then it is up to the group to decide if we are right or 
wrong.

I do not think we have wasted time, But I do still think we are seeing people 
who have an issue with the way your recommendation opens up the size of the 
'funnel.'  So while I believe we made progress, I do not feel I can call 
consensus on this issue.   Perhaps Evan feels differently. We have not yet 
discussed the specific issue.

And I believe that it was one of the conclusion of last Thursday's meeting that 
I would ask the question.  So I have.

Thank you

a.