Re: [gnso-rap-dt] revised WHOIS note

[Beau Brendler <beaubrendler@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Agree with Roland, would vote against dismissing WHOIS outright, sorry  
to have missed vote
Beau Brendler

Sent from my iPhone

On 23/07/2009, at 3:35 PM, Roland Perry  
<roland@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> In message <EF540DBF36AD494ABA9956846D1C0968@xxxxxxxxxxx>, at  
> 15:00:20 on Wed, 22 Jul 2009, Greg Aaron <gaaron@xxxxxxxxxxxx> writes
> > So, I need to know if anyone would like to switch their vote.  If  
> > so please
> > indicate explicitly on the list by 22:00 UTC tomorrow so that the  
> > tally can
> > be accurately recorded in the note to Council.  Rod, Mike, and  
> > Roland, can
> > you confirm your positions -- do you agree with a and b as per
> > http://forum.icann.org/lists/gnso-rap-dt/msg00255.html ?  If not,  
> > please
> > describe.
> There's only a short time to go (could we have longer than this in  
> future, we could easily be travelling), and I wasn't on the call.
> I can't agree to dismiss WHOIS problems because a registration that  
> has demonstrably false WHOIS (eg "Mickey Mouse, Disneyland") must be  
> indicative of some kind of abuse. It's also the case that some tlds  
> have geographic qualifications (eg "Resident in country X") and a  
> WHOIS indicating a different country would have to raise questions.
> --
> Roland Perry