Return to newtlds Forum - Message Thread - FAQ

Username: Amadeus
Date/Time: Fri, June 23, 2000 at 8:58 AM GMT
Browser: Netscape Communicator V4.71 using Windows NT
Score: 5
Subject: A managed heirarchy

Message:
 

 
Introducing new top level domains will be a waste of time unless the new heirarchies are properly managed. i.e. Not the complete chaos that has ensued so far.

The *.com domain is an utter mess. It's flat. Not the way DNS was supposed to be used at all. It is also rapidly spreading into *.net, *.org and others.

Domain squatting, trademark infringement and other issues can be solved by managing the heirarchy properly. After all what else are the registrars being paid for?

I propose that second and third level domains are reserved exclusively for domain administration purposes in addition to the top level domains, end users should only be allowed access to 4th level domains. Registrars should only be given access to register domains in the 4th level where the namespace is likely to be flat.

A set of generic administrative categories should be created under the top level domains.

Examples:

books.com
software.com
computers.com
plumbers.com
electronics.com
research.com

trademarks.org
animals.org
lobbyist.org
parody.org
freespeech.org
society.org

Below these first level general categories could be either country specific domain entries.

Examples:

US.trademarks.org
UK.trademarks.org
FR.trademarks.org

US.plumbers.com
UK.plumbers.com
IT.plumbers.com

Or, more specific categories which relate to the more general category they are within.

os.software.com
pim.software.com
ss.software.com
office.software.com

cpu.electronics.com
pda.electronics.com

medical.research.com
environmental.research.com

etc etc etc.

Then when someone wishes to register a domain, they should be strictly required to specify the categories which they wish to register within. Anyone found to be registering in inappropriate categories should have those entries removed.

Web browsers and other services could then actually make use of the domain heirarchy. Looking for a plumber? Guess where.

None of this is rocket science.

 


Message Thread:


Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Cookies Policy