Re: [soac-newgtldapsup-wg] rev 2.19-1 after listening to the phone call.

[Evan Leibovitch <evan@xxxxxxxxx>]

On 21 October 2010 15:18, Eric Brunner-Williams <ebw@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>wrote:

>
> On 10/21/10 3:05 PM, Avri Doria wrote:
>
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> But we held a poll.
>>
>
> Where are the results? Not the summary, but results that show how each WG
> member is represented as having indicated a preference?
>
>
Sorry folks. Here is a CSV dump of the survey that should be usable in any
spreadsheet program.

- Evan

"Response ID","Respondent Key","Date Submitted","Status","Contact 
ID","Comments","IP 
Address","Longitude","Latitude","Country","City","Region","Postal","Name of 
respondent:","The issue of bundling applications in different scripts to 
encourage support of underserved communities, should be","Ref 2.2 (6)In light 
of complexity of the calculation that established the basis for the USD$100,000 
base cost, it is difficult to determine what, if any of the fee should be 
eliminated for applicants meeting the requirements for support. It is therefore 
suggested that this should be subject to further investigation before any 
recommendations were made on the issue of fee reduction on this basis","Ref 
2.2.1Price reductions should be implemented to encourage the build out of IDNs 
in small or underserved languages, with the exact amount and timing of the 
support to be determined. One way this might be accomplished is through 
bundling of applications","Ref 2.2.1 aEach application requesting support for 
under-served languages must have explicit endorsement from within the language 
community to be served.","Ref 2.2.1 bAll applicants requesting support for 
under-served languages must meet the other criteria of support including 
need.","Ref 2.3.1 (a)The ICANN Program Development Director should be","Ref 
2.3.1 (c)(i)Given that Registrars may not be open to this specific proposal 
(voluntary contributions to a development fund), it should not be included in 
the JAS report","Ref 2.5 (d) iThere should be an effort to encourage shared 
risk pools among applicants who meet the requirements for support.","Ref 2.5. 
(d) iiApplicants in shared risk pools should have a lower (or zero) cost 
requirement for the Continued Operations Instrument.","Ref 2.6 (a) 
(ii)Financial Continued Operation Instrument period for the financial 
instrument should be shortened from 3 years to 1 year.","Ref 2.7 (a)For-profit 
enterprises should not be included in the categories receiving aid.","Ref 2.8 
(a) (i)Brands and other marketing oriented gTLDS should not be included among 
those entitled to receive support.","Ref 2.9 (d)There should be exemptions for 
some applicants who have Government support from the disqualification for 
having government support","Ref 2.9 (e)Only community applicants, and not 
commercial applicant, regardless of need should be exempt from prohibition 
related to Government support."
"15","57299","2010-10-15 
05:52:32","Complete","","","90.6.137.163","6.1667","47.6333","France","Vesoul","A6","","Sebastien
 
B","appendix","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","staff","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"5","54380","2010-10-14 
12:11:52","Complete","","","61.113.174.133","139.7514","35.685","Japan","Tokyo","40","","Rafik
 
Dammak","main","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","staff","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"16","57695","2010-10-15 
08:47:21","Complete","","","66.243.240.71","-120.4703","46.979","United 
States","Ellensburg","WA","98926","Elaine 
Pruis","appendix","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","discretion","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Disagree","Agree"
"14","56089","2010-10-14 
18:50:09","Complete","","","206.53.153.253","-97","38","United 
States","","","","carlos 
aguirre","main","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","staff","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"2","54331","2010-10-14 
11:52:23","Complete","","","68.15.42.104","-71.3187","41.8387","United 
States","Seekonk","MA","02771","avri","main","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","consultant","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree"
"3","54332","2010-10-14 
11:50:41","Complete","","","99.234.167.190","-79.4168","43.6667","Canada","Toronto","ON","","Evan
 
Leibovitch","appendix","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","consultant","Disagree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree"
"4","54334","2010-10-14 
11:50:52","Complete","","","81.17.243.251","-6.9261","52.8408","Ireland","Carlow","01","","Michele
 
Neylon","appendix","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","discretion","Disagree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree"
"6","54601","2010-10-14 
12:32:07","Complete","","","10.0.3.107","","","","","","","BAUDOUIN 
SCHOMBE","main","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","none","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"7","54602","2010-10-14 
22:26:18","Complete","","","67.255.5.237","-97","38","United 
States","","","","Eric 
Brunner-Williams","main","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","none","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree"
"8","54925","2010-10-14 
12:55:19","Complete","","","200.47.11.60","-58.6725","-34.5875","Argentina","Buenos
 Aires","07","","Anthony 
Harris","outside","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree","discretion","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree"
"9","55433","2010-10-14 
14:46:58","Complete","","","41.230.131.231","9","34","Tunisia","","","","Tijani 
BEN 
JEMAA","appendix","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","staff","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree","Agree","Agree"
"10","55752","2010-10-14 
16:18:47","Complete","","","197.224.59.199","","","","","","","Dave 
Kissoondoyal","appendix","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","consultant","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"11","55855","2010-10-14 
16:33:43","Complete","","","70.49.69.49","-73.5833","45.5","Canada","Montreal","QC","","Alan
 
Greenberg","main","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree","discretion","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Agree"
"13","55941","2010-10-14 
17:23:25","Complete","","","68.50.129.68","-77.0427","38.9068","United 
States","Washington","DC","20036","Andrew 
Mack","main","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","consultant","Disagree","Agree","Agree","Agree","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree","Disagree"