[gnso-idng] Re: same string registered at 2nd level across different IDN gTLDs [RE: [gnso-idng] rethinking IDN gTLDs]

[Eric Brunner-Williams <ebw@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Avri Doria wrote:
> hi,
>
> Thanks.
>
> Chuck is this the same for you?
>
> Eric, I did not think this was what you said.

Correct. In my example the registrant in tld-in-ldh may register the 
same string, or a translation, in tld-in-idn, where the pre-validation 
policy prevents confusion.
In general, I try for less restrictions, as registration policy may be 
substituted without loss of generality for the shared purpose a common 
equity ownership provides.
If you can find a better test than the non-confusion of the users of 
the resolvable resources, in the presence of plural, not singular 
resources, we should use it. If not, it seems to be the best standard 
available, and significantly better than "somebody in MdR is 
confused", which is the current standard.

Eric